
Most authors imagine a publisher settling in with a cup of tea and reading their manuscript from beginning to end. It’s a comforting fantasy—but far from reality. The truth of how publishers evaluate a novel is simple and a little confronting:
Publishers rarely read to the end of a submission. In fact, many won’t read past the first page. Some won’t read past the first paragraph. A few can tell from the first sentence whether the manuscript is ready for publication.
As managing editor at Alkira Publishing, I’ve assessed hundreds of submissions. And I can often tell—within moments—whether a book has the professional polish required to hold a reader’s attention for 80,000 words.
This isn’t harshness. It’s practicality. Publishers receive a constant flow of submissions, and they stop reading the moment their attention drops. Readers do the same. The difference is that publishers know why their attention drops.
And that’s the “secret map” authors rarely get to see.
Today, I’m sharing it.
Watch the video or read the blog post below.
Why Gut Feeling Isn’t Enough
Many authors rely on intuition to polish their books. Gut feeling is wonderful—for the first draft. But professional‑level writing requires more than instinct.
Think of the drafting process like this:
- First draft: Write freely. Follow the creative impulse.
- Second draft: Apply craft knowledge.
- Third draft: Integrate feedback from beta readers or a manuscript appraisal.
- Final polish: Evaluate your book using the same criteria publishers use.
Even if you’re self‑publishing, these criteria matter. Publishers read submissions the way readers read books. Readers don’t analyse craft—they simply respond to whether the writing works. The criteria are built around what keeps readers reading.
What Publishers Look For
While every publisher has preferences, the core criteria are remarkably consistent. At Alkira Publishing, we look for manuscripts where:
- The plot is well structured, well paced, and conceptually sound.
- Characters are complex, believable, and distinct.
- Dialogue feels natural and voices are differentiated.
- The prose is clear, active, and professionally crafted.
- The book is not overwritten—no info dumps, no unnecessary repetition, no irrelevant scenes.
- Point of view is consistent with no head‑hopping.
- Language is conscious and responsible, avoiding unnecessary bias or stereotyping.
- Themes and worldbuilding are coherent and well developed.
If any one of these elements is clearly missing, we stop reading.
How Publishers Evaluate a Submission
Authors can never read their own work the way a publisher or reader does. You know your story intimately. We come to it knowing nothing. How do publishers evaluate a novel? Your job is to convince us—quickly—that your book is worth our time.
Here’s the order in which we evaluate a submission:
1. The First Paragraph Must Hook Us
If the opening doesn’t engage, we won’t read on. A strong first paragraph signals confidence, clarity, and control of craft.
2. The Prose Must Demonstrate Professional Skill
We look for:
- Active, engaging writing
- Clear expression
- No wordiness
- No information dumps
- No technical slips
One of the biggest red flags? A manuscript that opens with a present participle. It signals a lack of craft education immediately.
3. The Main Character Must Appear First—and Alone
Readers need time to connect with the protagonist before meeting secondary characters. From the moment a character appears, we evaluate:
- Complexity
- Distinct voice
- Natural dialogue
A quick test: If you remove the “he said/she said,” do your characters still sound different?
4. The Setting Must Be Clear Early On
Time, place, and cultural context should be established without dumping information. Show, don’t tell—but make sure it’s there.
5. Point of View Must Be Consistent
No head‑hopping. No confusion.
If all of this is solid, we’ll usually read to the 25% mark. By then, we expect:
- The inciting incident
- The protagonist’s goals
- A sense of the antagonist
- A clear idea of the story’s direction
- Rising tension and meaningful stakes
Editors read submissions fast. These elements must be clear and strong—not vague.
What We Look For After the 25% Mark
If your manuscript passes the early test, we continue looking for:
- A strong, well‑paced structure
- Rising challenges for the protagonist
- A balance of wins and losses
- Both inner and outer character arcs
- Character development driven by action
- Consistent worldbuilding
- Thematic depth
- Scenes that serve multiple purposes
Every scene must earn its place. If a scene only does one thing, it’s probably obsolete.
Avoiding Common Pitfalls
1. The “Too Easy” Trap
A story where everything goes right is dull. Add obstacles—social, emotional, relational, cultural—to create tension.
2. The “Too Hard” Trap
If the protagonist never wins, readers become frustrated or depressed. Balance is key.
3. Overusing First‑Person Present‑Tense Thoughts
In a third‑person past‑tense narrative, italicised thoughts should be rare. Anything more than the occasional single sentence breaks the flow.
Creativity vs. Craft
Some authors fear that these criteria stifle creativity. They don’t. Your first draft is for creativity. Your editing stage is for craft.
If you’re submitting your book to an agent or selective publisher, these points of good craft matter a great deal because your book is being evaluated by editors who know what makes good writing. And they know that books with all these things in place are books that readers will read. They can’t afford to pick up a book that fail to grab readers and hold their attention.
And if you’re self-publishing, it’s the readers who do the evaluation. These guidelines exist because following them ensures that your book has the best chance of engaging readers.
Professional standards aren’t arbitrary rules—they’re acts of respect:
- Respect for the reader’s time
- Respect for the craft of storytelling
- Respect for your own work
Even big publishers have strict criteria. One Random House editor rejected any manuscript that used dialogue tags other than “said.” She also rejected anything that overused adverbs. You don’t have to be that strict—but you do need to understand what professionals look for.
The Bottom Line
A messy first draft is normal—even for seasoned authors. The magic happens in revision. When you understand how publishers evaluate a manuscript, you can refine your work with clarity and confidence.
If you want the full checklist we use at Alkira Publishing, you’ll find it in the description of the original video—and the deeper guidance is in my books Novel Writing Mastery and The Elements of Active Prose.
Has this changed the way you see your work‑in‑progress? I’d love to hear.
Resources
Alkira Publishing supports authors with editing, book design, and hybrid publishing. Need help writing or publishing your book? Contact us today.
Get advice for navigating the publishing world. Sign up here to our information for authors’ newsletter. You’ll get articles on writing, editing and publishing sent to your inbox as well as a FREE Novel Revision Checklist to help you get your novel ready for publication.



I changed the beginning of my novel, and it’s now very unconventional. It kind of violates your ‘rule three’, but I think it still works.
It appears to begin in third person past tense. But it actually only appears that way. At the 800-word mark, the story is interrupted by something that happens. It turns out this was only a frame story being told by a second main character, about another main character, to the primary main character, and the story is actually in first person present tense.
So that first 800 words was only a remembrance, but it still sets up an important mystery. It’s actually very clear and not confusing at all, but it’s a very different beginning from any other story I’ve ever read or written.
I know that sounds preposterous, but it works. On the surface, that sounds like it would not work. But it does. I think this might be a case of understanding the rules well enough to know how and when to break them.
The followed character in the frame story is just a little girl, but she is eventually revealed as the adult love interest of the main protagonist/narrator. So it’s a setup followed by a payoff.
This might not be enough to explain why it works, but it does, and once I discovered this you could’ve knocked me over with a feather, as it is about the last thing I would’ve expected. But even though I can’t explain it any further at the moment, I’d love to hear what you think about that.
When I read the first bit of a book, I’m not ticking these things off or even consciously looking for them, I’m just reading, and the words either work to grab me or they don’t. These are just generalities.
But yes, when you know the general guidelines and why they exist, then you can know when not following them works and you can use that diversion from the norm to great effect. I’ve done it myself in my own Worlds Within Worlds series which has past tense and present tense chapters, not usually recommended, but for that book, it’s perfect. What you describe sounds fine to me, but regardless of how it fits into the rest of the story, that first paragraph has to grab the reader all by itself.
ik ben geïntregeerd 😉
Thank you so much, Ms. Newland. What you are saying makes perfect sense.
I also need to thank you even more, as you alerted me to present participial phrases beginning scenes, and how that should be approached.
I’d been doing that intuitively and not consciously, and did not realize that it was problematic. I hadn’t done it all that often, but this got me to go through all 935,000 words in novels I have written and rewrite every single instance.
This alerted me to what it might be an even bigger issue, which was using action beats as single clauses leading into a line of dialogue, and in some cases, it was a single-line paragraph ending with a comma (!) I did not realize that was grammatically incorrect, because it actually still works. It’s not going to confuse any reader to do that.
But since this is frowned on by the powers that be, I went in and rewrote every single one of them. It took me two days to get comfortable with that, and two more passes through everything. But now I am vigilant about these things.
So those are issues of breaking the rules without understanding them first, and that underlines the necessity of understanding the rules before one can make an educated decision about whether to break them or not.
I’m glad I could help. I’m just pleased to hear that you are being so diligent. Going through all those words is quite admirable.
Some of these things may not confuse readers but they will make the book look unprofessional. I think if making the way we format and punctuate our books fit the established conventions doesn’t diminish what we’re trying to say, then it’s best to abide by them. But some cases do warrant an alternate approach; if you were writing lyrical prose rather than straight prose, for instance, then a comma at the end of a line would not be an issue, as lyrical prose is somewhere between poetry and prose. But if the whole work isn’t lyrical prose, then you have to be careful how you deal with the sections that are. As you say, knowing the conventions helps you know when you can diverge from them, and also helps give you some idea of how to handle any divergence effectively.